chicago apartments

presenting: chicago’s vintage restaurants

a tenant doesn't just lease an apartment.  a tenant leases a neighborhood.  so here at domu we try our best to educate our chicago tenants about the neighborhoods in which they live.  that's why we created the chicago history map.  pound for pound, we think the chicago history map is the most original and addicting presentation of chicago history in all of cyberspace. (full disclosure: we think everything about domu is great.)

so, anyway, in observance of chicago restaurant week 2012, we've decided to unveil a new history map category honoring the city’s “vintage restaurants.” a vintage restaurant, as we loosely define it, is any restaurant that’s been open for more than half a century. we figure if you can keep it going for 50 years you must be doing something right, even if, as in the case of jimmy’s red hots (founded 1954), the entire menu consists of a polish sausage, a hot dog, a tamale, french fries, and soda.

so have a look. there are 58 vintage restaurants on the map, including nine pizzerias, eight diners, and seven hot dog joints. a list of these classic eateries, in age order, appears below. trivia buffs will be glad to learn that the five oldest restaurants in chicago are schaller’s pump (1881), daley’s restaurant (1892), the berghoff (1898), the walnut room (1907), and cafe brauer (1908). these are the only restaurants in town where someone could have celebrated the final out of a chicago cubs world series championship. the oldest italian restaurant in the city is italian village (1927). the oldest chinese restaurant is orange garden (1924), which is actually on irving park road and not in chinatown. the oldest restaurant in chinatown is won kow (1927), which was a favorite dining spot for the notorious al capone.

in cooking up our list, we might have decided that a restaurant inherently requires table service, but that would have eliminated the swedish bakery, which has been selling assorted scandanavian treats from the same andersonville location since at least 1929 (and perhaps earlier). it would also have 86’d the legendary calumet fisheries, which has been producing delicious oak-smoked seafood since 1948 and was recently recognized as an american classic by the james beard foundation.

we might also have decided that a restaurant necessarily serves something other than flavored sugar water, but that would have eliminated mario’s italian lemonade, the exclusive source of drinkable italian ice on taylor street every summer since 1954.

we also imposed no requirement that a vintage restaurant still be operating from the same location in which it first opened, probably because we didn’t have the heart to omit such jewels as lou mitchell’s, which opened in 1923, but moved across the street in 1949, or manny’s, which opened in 1942, but moved a few times before settling into its current digs in 1964. we also waived any requirement that the restaurant be open for at least 50 consecutive years, mainly because we couldn’t imagine the map being complete without cafe brauer, which opened in lincoln park in 1908, closed in 1941, then reopened again in 1990.

is our list exhaustive? we doubt it. it’s probably safe to assume that there have been some unintentional omissions. so, if you know of one, please bring it to our attention. we’ll add it to the history map, lickety-split. until then, bon appetit!

1 1881 Schaller's Pump
2 1892 Daley's Restaurant
3 1898 The Berghoff
4 1907 The Walnut Room
5 1908 Cafe Brauer
6 1909 Pompei Bakery
7 1921 Margie's Candies
8 1921 Valois
9 1921 The Green Door Tavern
10 1923 Lou Mitchell's
11 1924 Lindy's Chili
12 1924 Orange Garden
13 1925 Erickson's Deli
14 1927 Won Kow
15 1927 Italian Village
16 1928 Swedish Bakery
17 1931 Tufano's Vernon Park Tap
18 1932 Twin Anchors
19 1933 Bertucci's Restaurant & Lounge
20 1933 Bruna's
21 1933 The Cape Cod Room
22 1934 The Billy Goat Tavern
23 1937 The Diner Grill
24 1938 Al's No. 1 Italian Beef
25 1938 Frances' Deli
26 1938 The Pump Room
27 1939 Blackie's Restaurant & Tavern
28 1939 White Palace Grill
29 1939 Jim's Original
30 1940 Marie's Pizza & Liquors
31 1941 Gene & Georgetti
32 1942 Manny's
33 1943 Uno Chicago Grill
34 1945 Ann Sather's
35 1946 Coletti's
36 1947 Marcello's (Father & Son)
37 1947 Home Run Inn
38 1947 Veteran Tamale Shop
39 1948 The Woodlawn Tap (Jimmy's)
40 1948 Superdawg
41 1948 Calumet Fisheries
42 1950 The Bagel
43 1950 Podhalanka Polska
44 1952 Club Lago
45 1954 Jimmy's Red Hots
46 1954 Mario's Italian Lemonade
47 1955 Pizzeria Due
48 1955 Johnny's Wee Nee Wagon
49 1959 Moody's Pub
50 1959 Mickey's Drive-In
51 1959 Aurelio's Pizza Of Homewood
52 1960 Morry's Deli
53 1961 Palermo's
54 1961 Susie's Drive-In
55 1961 Butch McGuire's
56 1962 Monastero's Ristorante
57 1962 Stella's Diner
58 1962 Medici 57

« Back to blogs

Tell us what you think!

Andrew says:

we intend to update the list sometime in the very near future. thank you for your interest.

Neil says:

Any idea when this list will be updated? Looking forward to it!

Cheryl says:

The Berghoff shouldn't be on that list. It's not the original restaurant, it just has the same name as the one that closed.

Andrew says:

thank you, tony! we will add it to a soon-to-be released update to the original list.

tony papaleo says:

Top Notch Beefburgers in Beverly..... not their original location, but they go back to the 40s....

Andrew says:

Add Palace Grill to the list! And thank you, Neil. One webpage coming right up!

Neil says:

I passed by the Palace Grill on my way hope from work. The sign outside says "Since 1938". http://www.palacegrillonmadison.com/

guest says:

What ever became of Diana's, the Greek restaurant on Halsted?

Skarl says:

Don't forget Dinkel's Bakery! Opened in 1922!

Alex says:

I suppose Miller's Pub counts as a pub rather than a restaurant. That was established in the 1930, I believe.

Sharon Woodhouse says:

For more Oldest Chicago, check out David Witter's book, "Oldest Chicago," which came out in Feb. 2011. Includes many of these places plus the oldest things in dozens of other categories.

Andrew says:

Thanks to anyone and everyone who brings additional vintage restaurants to our attention here at domu. We tried our best to find everything, but it's much harder than it looks. We will soon update the history map to include the following additional restaurants:

Lem's Bar-B-Q
Vito & Nick's
Moon's Sandwich Shop
Rainbow Cone
Roeser's Bakery
Club 81 Too

jpp says:

peanut says:

The Ramova Grill has been open since 1929(http://chicagoist.com/2005/07/26/spotlight_on_the_ramova_grill.php)...

Kristi says:

Rainbow Cone should get a spot before Mario's Italian Ice, no?